Williams became the first
New England school and first NESCAC member
to win the NCAA title in 2003 when they downed
Gustavous Adolphus (MN) 67-65 in Salem, VA.
Williams has advanced to the Final Four six times since 1997.
Champions: 2003
Runner-Up: 2010 & 2004
3rd Place: 2011, 1998 & 1997
NCAA Division III Tournament record through March, 2011:
| Coach | Appearances | Record | Notes |
| Mike Maker | 2 | 8-2 (.800) | |
| Dave Paulsen |
4 |
10-3 (.769) |
'03 & '04 NABC Nat'l Coach of
the Year |
| Harry Sheehy | 6 | 15-6 (.714) | |
| TOTALS |
12 |
33-11 (.750) |
|
Year |
Opponent | Result | Score | Coach |
| 2011 | Husson | Won | 86-83 OT | Mike Maker |
| Becker | Won | 84-63 | ||
| Va. Wesleyan | Won | 79-73 | ||
| Amherst | Won | 77-71 | ||
| Wooster | Lost | 73-71 | 3rd Place | |
| 2010 | Me.-Farmington | Won | 83-64 | Mike Maker |
| SUNYIT | Won | 104-70 | ||
| Brandeis | Won | 71-57 | ||
| Guilford | Won | 97-85 | ||
| Wis.-Stevens Point | Lost | 78-73 | 2nd Place | |
| 2007 | Brockport | Lost | 74-66 | Dave Paulsen '87 |
| 2004 | Salem St. | Won | 91-77 | Dave Paulsen '87 |
| Brockport | Won | 78-50 | ||
| Keene St. | Won | 79-64 | ||
| Amherst | Won | 86-81 | ||
| Wis.-Stevens Point | Lost | 84-82 | 2nd Place | |
| 2003 | Salem St. | Won | 94-67 | Dave Paulsen '87 |
| Hamilton | Won | 76-65 | ||
| Amherst | Won | 91-74 | ||
| Wooster | Won | 74-72 OT | ||
| Gust. Adolphus | Won | 67-65 | National Champions | |
| 2002 | Cazenovia | Won | 121-49 | Dave Paulsen '87 |
| Rochester (NY) | Lost | 66-51 | Second Round | |
| 2000 | Springfield | Lost | 75-74 | Harry Sheehy '75 |
| 1998 |
Trinity (CT) |
Won | 89-63 | Harry Sheehy '75 |
| Springfield | Won | 82-75 | ||
| Hamilton | Won | 90-69 | ||
| St. Lawrence | Won | 100-82 | ||
| Wis.-Platteville | Lost | 82-68 | ||
| Wilkes | Won | 105-93 | 3rd Place | |
| 1997 | Wentworth | Won | 76-51 | Harry Sheehy '75 |
| Amherst | Won | 86-63 | ||
| Richard Stockton | Won | 85-61 | ||
| Rowan | Won | 71-62 | ||
| Neb. Wesleyan | Lost | 101-90 | ||
| Alvernia | Won | 78-77 | 3rd Place | |
| 1996 | Plymouth St. | Won | 78-62 | Harry Sheehy '75 |
| Bowdoin | Won | 91-64 | ||
| Rowan | Lost | 85-77 | Sectional Semifinals | |
| 1995 | Colby | Won | 80-66 | Harry Sheehy '75 |
| Mass-Dartmouth | Won | 61-59 | ||
| Wilkes | Lost | 91-89 OT | Sectional Semifinals | |
| 1994 | Worcester St. | Won | 108-88 | Harry Sheehy '75 |
| Mass-Dartmouth | Lost | 82-78 | Second Round | |
