Overall Record: 25-12 Conference Record: 9-3
| Date | Opponent | Score | Status | |
| 03/22/09 | Eastern Conn. St. @ Sagauro HS, Scottsdale, Az. | L, 10-1 | Final - 9 innings | Boxscore |
| Eastern Conn. St. @ Sagauro HS, Scottsdale, Az. | L, 6-4 | Final | Boxscore | |
| 03/23/09 | Gust. Adolphus @ Snedigar Park, Chandler. Az. | L, 14-12 | Final - 9 innings | Boxscore |
| Gust. Adolphus @ Snedigar Park, Chandler, Az. | L, 9-6 | Final | Boxscore | |
| 03/24/09 | Calvin @ Gene Autry Complex, Mesa, Az. | L, 10-4 | Final - 8 innings | Boxscore |
| Calvin @ Gene Autry Complex, Mesa, Az. | W, 12-3 | Final | Boxscore | |
| 03/25/09 | Hamline @ Gene Autry Complex, Mesa, Az. | W, 7-6 | Final | Boxscore |
| Hamline @ Gene Autry Complex, Mesa, Az. | W, 9-8 | Final - 8 innings | Boxscore | |
| 03/27/09 | Middlebury @ Phoenix, Ariz. * | W, 11-6 | Final | Boxscore |
| 03/28/09 | Middlebury @ Phoenix, Ariz. * | W, 11-6 | Final | Boxscore |
| Middlebury @ Phoenix, Ariz. * | W, 9-2 | Final - 9 innings | Boxscore | |
| 03/30/09 | at Thomas @ Snedigar Complex (Chandler, AZ) | W, 17-2 | Final | Boxscore |
| 03/31/09 | Thomas @ Snedigar Complex (Chandler, AZ) | W, 12-4 | Final | Boxscore |
| 04/01/09 | at Thomas @ Snedigar Complex (Chandler, AZ) | W, 22-8 | Final | Boxscore |
| 04/05/09 | at Babson | W, 9-8 | Final | Boxscore |
| 04/07/09 | at Fordham | W, 5-2 | Final | Boxscore Photos |
| 04/11/09 | Amherst * | L, 12-1 | Final - 7 innings | Boxscore |
| Amherst * | L, 4-1 | Final - 9 innings | Boxscore Photos | |
| 04/13/09 | MCLA | W, 7-6 | Final - 9 innings | Boxscore Photos |
| 04/14/09 | at Elms | W, 15-4 | Final | Boxscore |
| 04/16/09 | Castleton | W, 11-2 | Final - 9 innings | Boxscore Photos |
| 04/17/09 | at Hamilton * | W, 11-1 | Final | Boxscore |
| 04/18/09 | at Hamilton * | W, 10-3 | Final | Boxscore |
| at Hamilton * | W, 16-9 | Final | Boxscore | |
| 04/22/09 | Southern Vt. | W, 3-0 | Final | Boxscore |
| 04/25/09 | at Wesleyan (Conn.) * | W, 10-5 | Final - 7 innings | Boxscore |
| at Wesleyan (Conn.) * | W, 13-8 | Final - 9 innings | Boxscore | |
| 04/26/09 | Wesleyan (Conn.) * | L, 8-6 | Final | Boxscore Photos |
| 04/28/09 | at Skidmore | W, 15-6 | Final | Boxscore |
| 04/29/09 | RPI | L, 5-3 | Final - 9 innings | Boxscore Photos |
| 04/30/09 | Springfield | W, 6-1 | Final - 9 innings | Boxscore Photos |
| 05/02/09 | MIT | L, 5-4 | Final - 7 innings | Boxscore |
| MIT | W, 3-2 | Final - 7 innings | Boxscore | |
| 05/03/09 | Amherst @ Wahconah Park - Pittsfield, MA * | W, 8-5 | Final | Boxscore Photos |
| 05/08/09 | Tufts | W, 18-5 | Final | Boxscore Photos |
| 2009 NESCAC Baseball Championship - Game 1 | ||||
| 05/09/09 | at Trinity (Conn.) | L, 8-3 | Final | Boxscore |
| 2009 NESCAC Baseball Championship - Game 4 | ||||
| at Tufts @ Williams | L, 15-9 | Final | Boxscore Photos | |
| 2009 NESCAC Baseball Championship - Game 5 | ||||
| Home games in bold. * = Conference games. | ||||






